You’ve built a great restaurant. You’re active on social media, your guests rave about the food. But when someone googles your spot, nothing shows up. What gives?
This is a frustrating but common issue in restaurant marketing. Even restaurants with great reputations struggle with visibility online, especially if the basics of SEO (search engine optimization) for restaurants are overlooked.
To understand what might be going wrong and how to fix it, I spoke with restaurant tech consultants Dan Durkin and Rachel Morgan from Back of House.
Three Fixes for Common SEO Struggles for Restaurants
Visibility in local search isn’t just about popularity — you have to make sure search engines have the right signals to connect diners to your restaurant. Many of these signals come down to simple, manageable details.
Some top reasons why your restaurant might not be showing up in search:
- An incomplete or unclaimed Google Business Profile
- Outdated or inconsistent information across platforms like Yelp or TripAdvisor
- Using generic keywords instead of location-specific phrases
- Not responding to reviews, signaling disengagement to customers and Google
These may seem like small details, but they have a big impact on how you show up in local search. Here’s how to turn it around.
1. Take Control of Your Online Presence
Starting at square one: If you haven’t claimed and fully developed your Google Business Profile, your restaurant may not show up at all.
“I see this a lot,” says Rachel. “A lot of times, Yelp or TripAdvisor will appear for a restaurant, but the listing hasn’t been claimed, and the data is incorrect. If your name, address, or phone number is inconsistent across platforms, it hurts your visibility. Google cross-references all of that.”
Dan agrees: “It’s one of the most important things you can do. There are a lot of fields in a Google Business Profile, and you want to be as thorough as possible. Cram those fields with relevant info and constantly update with promos, events, and new menu items. That owner activity helps your ranking.”
Make sure your profile includes current hours, accurate contact info, photos, and links to your website and social channels. All of these details help search engines and customers find you.
2. Optimize Your Local SEO
Local SEO is what makes your restaurant show up in search results when someone types in “brunch near me.” It’s about connecting your restaurant to nearby customers in their moments of discovery.
So how do you compete in those local results?
Start by using location-based keywords on your website and Google Business Profile. Rachel recommends, “Don’t just say ‘sports bar.’ Say ‘East Nashville sports bar.” Include the names of neighborhoods, landmarks, and other local phrases that potential diners might use.
Unsure where you stand in local search? Luckily, you don’t have to guess. Spot check tools made for restaurants show you how you’re doing in local search and what to improve.
A quick win: Link your website and social profiles back to your Google Business Profile. This reinforces your local presence and helps tie everything together.
3. Respond to Reviews ASAP
Online reviews do more than shape public perception — they also directly affect your visibility in search results. Whether it’s Google, Yelp, or TripAdvisor, reviews influence how your restaurant ranks and whether a potential diner chooses you over your competition.
Both Dan and Rachel stress the importance of customer review management as part of a restaurant marketing strategy. Tools like Localyser automate the tracking, replying, boosting, and analyzing of online reviews from all sources.
Dan says, “Whether it’s a glowing 5-star review or a frustrated 2-star, reply. That responsiveness can improve your rankings in map and search.”
“More reviews mean more credibility in Google’s eyes,” Rachel explains. “Higher ratings help you show up in map results. And responding to reviews builds trust, with both Google and potential customers.”
Subscribe to Our Monthly Marketing Newsletter
Get proven strategies and tools to attract new customers, boost engagement, and grow your brand.
She also emphasizes that your replies don’t need to be lengthy: “A simple acknowledgement goes a long way.” Quick and thoughtful responses show you care, which encourages more reviews and boosts your search visibility.
So, don’t leave those reviews hanging. Respond in good time, within 24 hours if possible. This shows both Google and your guests that your restaurant is active, attentive, and cares about the customer experience.
Technical SEO Issues That Hurt Restaurant Websites
Even well-designed restaurant websites can be dragged down by hidden technical issues. Dan says, “Google doesn’t like recommending buggy websites, so fixing small technical errors can make a big difference.”
The following are a few top tech issues that quietly hurt your search ranking:
- Mobile: Website performance plays a major role in how Google ranks you, especially on mobile devices. “Google uses mobile-first indexing, which means it evaluates your site based on how it performs on a phone,” says Rachel. “If your site isn’t mobile-friendly, you’re less likely to rank well in search results.”
- Page speed: “Attention spans are short and competition is high,” she adds. “The longer your website takes to load, the more likely visitors are to leave, and Google sees that as a signal that your site isn’t useful, which can lower your ranking.”
- PDF menus: If you still have PDF menus on your website, it’s time to make a change. “Google can’t easily read or index content inside PDFs, so your menu items won’t help your searchability,” Rachel explains. “Plus, they’re hard to use on mobile, especially when guests are quickly scanning for info.”
Rachel adds that search marketing for restaurants is evolving – fast. “GoogleAI is changing SEO,” she says. “There’s more emphasis on structured content, like menus in HTML and well-tagged info, so your restaurant can show up in AI-generated search answers.”
In other words, it’s no longer just about having a website. It’s about how that website is built and organized.
If that sounds overwhelming, don’t stress. All-in-one tools also include features that scan for technical issues that can quietly drag down your ranking. Platforms like Owner and Sociavore help track your visibility in local search results and let you know what to do to strengthen your search marketing for restaurants.
- Owner combines strong SEO with built-in tools for online ordering, CRM, and marketing, making it a more comprehensive investment for restaurants focused on growth.
- Sociavore offers SEO-friendly templates and essential features at a more affordable entry point, with less emphasis on advanced marketing and SEO automation.
Can Smaller Restaurants Compete in Search?
Absolutely! But it takes persistence and strategy. Competing organically – meaning without paid ads or shortcuts – relies on consistent, hands-on effort over time.
“If you’re doing it organically, be patient,” says Dan. “But there are tools and services that can help speed things up, like nudging guests to leave reviews, using AI to auto-respond, or hiring vendors that specialize in SEO for restaurants.”
Rachel emphasizes the importance of early momentum: “Get aggressive with reviews and responses early. And make sure your website is mobile-optimized from the start.”
The Bottom Line
Even the best food and service won’t matter if no one knows you exist. Word-of-mouth and loyal regulars help, but strong SEO for restaurants is what puts you on the map. It ensures people can find you when they search locally for their next meal.
As Dan says, “Show Google that you’re active, up-to-date, and engaged, and your search rankings will reflect that.”
Want Help Making Sense of It All?
All of this may feel like a lot to take on. SEO and local search can be tricky, especially when your focus is running a busy restaurant. But you’re not alone. Tools are available to streamline these restaurant marketing tasks.
The team at Back of House understands the pros and cons of these tools, and we’re here to help. We’ll take a look at your current setup and recommend solutions that fit your goals and budget. Book a consultation to get started.
